Table 1. Changes in Hunter color values of heat-treated (HT) and non-heat-treated (NHT)-PVA/PAA/NR@TOCNF colorimetric indicator films (CIFs) during storage at room temperature (25±2°C)

Sample Storage period (days) Hunter color value
L*1) a*2) b*3) ΔE4)
NHT-PVA/PAA/NR@TOCNF 0 41.95±3.475)a6) 39.17±1.72a 18.09±1.04a -
7 41.79±3.81a 38.95±1.51a 17.60±1.72a 3.94±1.55bc
14 41.73±3.32a 38.66±1.51a 17.50±1.26a 3.42±1.51abc
21 41.68±1.78a 38.86±1.77a 18.72±1.10a 2.58±0.75a
28 41.34±1.96a 38.29±1.34a 18.79±1.12a 2.66±0.84ab
35 41.25±3.19a 38.63±0.92a 18.85±1.34a 3.46±0.81abc
42 42.40±3.62a 37.80±1.71a 18.83±1.19a 4.06±1.28c
HT-PVA/PAA/NR@TOCNF 0 37.84±2.08a 31.74±3.39a 18.73±2.05a -
7 37.98±2.69a 31.74±3.39a 19.29±1.71a 5.46±1.36c
14 37.75±3.31a 32.36±3.49a 19.43±1.47a 4.38±2.11bc
21 37.23±0.91a 32.13±1.95a 18.19±1.41a 2.33±1.16a
28 37.32±1.40a 31.22±2.04a 19.07±1.13a 2.60±0.65a
35 37.50±1.35a 31.26±2.33a 18.62±1.61a 2.78±1.22a
42 37.54±1.58a 30.59±2.52a 19.22±0.70a 3.10±0.55ab
L*, degree of lightness (+100=white, 0=black).
a*, degree of redness (+100=red, −80=green).
b*, degree of yellowness (+70=yellow, −70=blue).
ΔE*, total color difference ([(L*n − L*0)2 + (a*n − a*0)2 + (b*n − b*0)2]1/2).
All values are mean±SD (n=5).
Values with different superscript letters (a-c) in the same column are significantly different at p<0.05 by Duncan’s multiple range test.