Table 3. The content of organic acids in barley-Makgeolli by fermented agent AO nuruk of Y204 according to the various fermentation temperature and period
F.T1)(℃) | Yeast2) | Organic acid | Fermentation period (day, mg/100 mL) |
0 | 2 | 4 | 6 | 8 |
15 | Control | Malic acid | 6.12±0.3a | 5.33±0.45b | 3.30±0.65c | 4.98±0.21b | 1.50±0.11d |
Lactic acid | 1.05±0.08d | 1.57±0.10d | 5.99±0.02c | 58.95±1.03a | 22.84±0.72b |
Acetic acid | 3.29±0.40d | 6.26±0.37c | 7.10±0.21b | n.d | 10.64±0.37a |
Citric acid | 13.11±0.90b | 11.35±0.66c | 8.83±0.04d | 25.61±0.98a | 5.75±0.14e |
Succinic acid | 0.29±0.06e | 1.32±0.09d | 4.82±0.71c | 34.34±0.89a | 10.95±0.46b |
Fumaric acid | 1.82±0.49a | 1.66±0.55a | n.d | 1.72±0.62a | n.d |
Propionic acid | 1.12±0.89bc | 2.06±0.61b | 2.03±0.86b | 5.01±0.78a | n.d |
Total | 26.81 | 29.55 | 32.07 | 130.61 | 51.69 |
Y204 | Malic acid | 8.95±0.22a | 6.06±0.54b | 6.25±0.40b | 10.08±0.95a | 8.96±0.73a |
Lactic acid | 1.08±0.27d | 1.30±0.21d | 1.98±0.21c | 4.47±0.20a | 3.34±0.39b |
Acetic acid | 1.11±0.50d | 10.74±0.59c | 12.05±0.52c | 20.39±1.00a | 18.48±1.03b |
Citric acid | 22.56±0.78a | 12.24±0.35b | 8.04±1.12d | 11.51±0.50b | 9.11±0.50c |
Succinic acid | 1.55±0.34d | 0.98±0.49d | 4.55±0.32c | 11.24±0.90a | 9.17±0.95b |
Fumaric acid | 1.77±0.43b | 2.54±0.67a | n.d | n.d | n.d |
Propionic acid | 2.60±0.41a | 2.04±0.31b | n.d | n.d | n.d |
Total | 39.61 | 35.89 | 32.88 | 57.69 | 49.06 |
20 | Control | Malic acid | 7.10±0.47c | 5.77±0.70d | 7.48±0.52c | 11.01±0.30b | 28.19±0.39a |
Lactic acid | n.d | 3.53±0.03c | 96.53±0.78a | 4.26±0.26c | 19.81±0.53b |
Acetic acid | 3.62±0.28c | 2.09±0.50d | 11.97±0.98a | 5.11±0.30b | n.d |
Citric acid | 16.32±0.91b | 8.62±0.11c | 4.61±0.26d | 4.13±0.32d | 19.12±0.41a |
Succinic acid | 2.04±0.10c | 8.78±0.59b | 4.56±0.45d | 7.00±0.29c | 39.49±0.80a |
Fumaric acid | 1.97±0.50b | n.d | n.d | n.d | 2.91±0.92a |
Propionic acid | 1.27±0.29b | n.d | n.d | n.d | 2.84±0.50a |
Total | 32.33 | 28.79 | 125.16 | 31.51 | 112.34 |
Y204 | Malic acid | 11.08±0.30c | 34.63±0.66b | 10.27±0.86c | 48.84±0.90a | 35.18±0.84b |
Lactic acid | 6.29±0.51d | 12.15±0.44c | 2.49±0.35e | 33.41±0.60a | 24.45±0.85b |
Acetic acid | 2.03±0.48d | n.d | 5.03±0.27b | 53.82±0.93a | 3.50±0.18c |
Citric acid | 20.43±1.04b | 8.55±0.54c | 4.53±0.08d | 24.28±0.52a | 20.96±1.03b |
Succinic acid | 1.27±0.38e | 8.84±0.28c | 7.63±0.52d | 29.43±0.58a | 22.22±1.11b |
Fumaric acid | 1.77±0.54b | n.d | n.d | 2.73±0.39a | 2.55±0.54a |
Propionic acid | 1.66±0.35a | n.d | n.d | 1.37±0.64a | 1.23±0.23a |
Total | 44.54 | 64.16 | 29.94 | 193.89 | 110.09 |
25 | Control | Malic acid | 4.10±0.10d | 19.30±0.84b | 5.36±0.52d | 51.19±0.96a | 7.94±1.05c |
Lactic acid | 1.76±0.10e | 9.56±0.11b | 2.81±0.12d | 41.25±1.05a | 6.11±0.22c |
Acetic acid | 5.66±0.12b | 3.95±0.39c | 1.43±0.16d | 58.91±0.60a | 0.74±0.61e |
Citric acid | 9.68±0.31b | 9.51±0.28b | 2.27±0.10d | 22.64±0.86a | 5.98±0.14c |
Succinic acid | 0.93±0.30d | 12.97±0.99a | 7.61±0.50c | 1.77±0.54c | 9.09±0.20b |
Fumaric acid | 1.62±0.51b | n.d | n.d | 2.98±0.61a | n.d |
Propionic acid | 1.53±0.88b | n.d | n.d | 2.53±0.52a | n.d |
Total | 25.28 | 55.28 | 19.48 | 181.27 | 29.87 |
Y204 | Malic acid | 11.30±0.52c | 15.69±0.90b | 11.68±0.49c | 51.19±0.98a | 8.98±1.01d |
Lactic acid | 4.01±0.11d | 8.45±0.44c | 9.98±0.42b | 41.25±0.53a | 8.06±0.39c |
Acetic acid | 17.87±1.04b | 8.58±0.13d | 11.15±0.17c | 58.91±1.00a | 9.41±0.04d |
Citric acid | 25.38±1.11a | 6.37±0.58c | 7.34±0.34c | 22.64±0.93b | 6.56±0.33c |
Succinic acid | 5.12±0.22a | 3.25±0.09b | 5.26±0.48a | 1.77±0.62c | 4.70±0.69a |
Fumaric acid | 2.00±0.51b | n.d | n.d | 2.98±0.39a | n.d |
Propionic acid | 1.83±0.18b | n.d | n.d | 2.53±0.48a | n.d |
Total | 67.51 | 42.33 | 45.41 | 181.27 | 37.71 |
1)F.T: Fermentation temperature
2)Control: Saccharomyces cerevisiae Fermivin, Y204: S. cerevisiae Y204
3)Means with different letters in the same row are significantly different (p<0.05) by ducan’s multiple range test.
4)Not detected