ClO2 gas conc. (ppm) | 0 | 15 | 30 | 45 | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Time (min) | 0 | 15 | 30 | 45 | 15 | 30 | 45 | 15 | 30 | 45 | |
L (lightness) | 1day | 26.27±1.43 | 25.34±1.09abcx | 23.73±1.85bcdx | 27.54±0.37ax | 24.27±2.95abcdx | 26.30±0.86abx | 22.47±2.52cdx | 22.94±3.18bcdx | 21.50±2.33dy | 22.55±0.72bcdy |
2day | 25.35±1.08ax | 26.63±4.55ax | 23.93±2.30ax | 24.94±3.31ax | 27.36±2.08ax | 26.72±4.58ax | 23.51±5.00ax | 24.22±0.22ax | 27.51±2.67ax | 27.64±0.33ax | |
3day | 24.51±2.70ax | 23.75±0.45ax | 29.02±4.47ax | 26.76±4.75ax | 24.97±2.89ax | 26.63±2.34ax | 25.17±2.79ax | 24.91±2.63ax | 27.39±1.03ax | 27.07±2.11ax | |
a (redness) | 1day | 9.46±1.11ax | 8.48±0.95abcx | 8.41±1.71abcx | 9.05±1.18abcx | 7.15±0.85cdey | 8.85±0.63abx | 7.36±0.24bcdy | 6.57±0.19dey | 7.69±0.32bcdy | 5.72±0.30ey |
2day | 8.55±0.51bcdxy | 9.38±0.92abcx | 6.71±0.95ex | 9.80±0.55abx | 10.69±1.69ax | 8.63±0.77bcdx | 8.68±0.36bcdx | 7.39±0.50dexy | 8.96±0.76bcdx | 7.79±0.83cdex | |
3day | 7.86±0.24abcy | 6.62±0.78cy | 9.27±1.77abx | 10.17±2.99ax | 7.28±1.02bcy | 8.09±0.94abcx | 8.86±0.83abcx | 8.70±1.02abcx | 9.42±0.68abx | 9.29±1.08abx | |
b (yelllowness) | 1day | 9.05±1.09ax | 7.82±0.69abcx | 8.81±0.73aby | 9.21±1.33ax | 7.59±0.14bcy | 8.27±1.13abx | 7.48±0.50bcx | 6.78±0.31cy | 6.69±0.44cy | 6.61±0.20cy |
2day | 8.10±0.71bcx | 8.83±0.90abcx | 6.96±0.57cy | 8.93±1.16abcx | 10.31±1.25ax | 9.63±1.11abx | 8.04±1.23bcx | 8.07±0.23bcx | 8.88±1.35abcx | 8.68±1.13abcx | |
3day | 7.38±0.68cx | 7.46±0.42cx | 11.10±1.76ax | 9.75±1.02abx | 8.81±1.28bcxy | 8.77±0.70bcx | 7.69±0.84cx | 7.96±0.26bcx | 8.94±0.86bcx | 8.98±1.30bcx | |
△E (total color difference) | 1day | 74.18±1.23bcdx | 76.46±1.66abcx | 74.99±0.81bcdx | 72.94±0.60dx | 75.78±2.76abcdx | 74.02±0.66cdx | 77.57±2.29abx | 76.99±2.90abcx | 78.49±2.23ax | 77.25±0.71abcx |
2day | 74.89±0.73ax | 72.66±3.85ax | 75.97±2.09ax | 76.62±3.39ax | 73.46±1.63ax | 73.81±3.77ax | 76.73±4.50ax | 75.74±0.24ax | 73.48±2.70ay | 72.60±0.09ay | |
3day | 75.58±2.40ax | 76.20±0.42ax | 71.86±3.76ax | 74.01±3.39ax | 75.22±2.61ax | 73.66±2.02ax | 75.08±2.34ax | 75.33±2.32ax | 73.07±1.02ay | 73.40±1.75ay |