Sample | Cultivation method | OCIG | CCWP | OCIG | CCWP | OCIG | CCWP | Control |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Size | Small | Small | Medium | Medium | Large | Large | Midium | |
Quality properties | Size | 59.44±6.50f | 49.96±6.00f (52.50±10.84) | 95.87±13.02c (98.00±10.62) | 82.07±8.79cd (89.08±10.76) | 158.67±20.05ab (149.33±16.24) | 191±25.99a (168.50±19.11) | 80.38±5.43cd (79.86±6.32) |
Soluble solid | 12.31±0.98c | 15.07±2.01a | 12.43±0.65c | 14.22±1.19ab | 11.08±0.54d | 13.87±1.22b | 14.91±0.79a | |
pH | 3.8±0.18c | 4.2±0.13ab | 4.14±0.08b | 4.27±0.13a | 4.31±0.08a | 4.32±0.20a | 4.06±0.18b | |
Acidity | 0.64±0.15a | 0.55±0.09ab | 0.52±0.07b | 0.51±0.09b | 0.46±0.08b | 0.54±0.19b | 0.56±0.12ab | |
SS/acidity | 26.84±0.36bc | 25.76±0.47a | 27.64±0.16c | 27.23±0.32b | 23.96±0.14d | 24.10±0.34b | 19.25±0.26a | |
Sensory attribute | ||||||||
Appearance | Gloss intensity | 6.18±2.84b | 8.01±2.96a | 6.91±2.74b | 7.87±2.93ab | 7.37±2.85b | 7.84±2.39ab | 8.62±2.33a |
Color intensity | 4.71±2.12b | 9.47±2.46a | 4.94±1.98b | 9.22±2.18a | 5.96±2.38c | 8.85±2.09a | 8.46±2.39a | |
Peel width | 5.93±2.43bc | 4.66±3.14c | 8.10±2.63b | 6.45±3.49c | 8.50±2.80b | 10.34±2.78a | 5.80±1.87c | |
Damage degree | 1.70±1.01b | 6.94±4.09a | 1.91±1.89b | 6.35±3.11a | 2.25±2.01b | 5.51±3.32a | 1.93±1.78b | |
Texture of peel | 3.01±2.07b | 6.58±3.57a | 3.66±2.63b | 7.15±2.73a | 4.32±2.39b | 7.38±3.23a | 3.65±1.74b | |
Odor | Sour | 5.36±3.55b | 6.33±4.01a | 5.93±3.06b | 6.97±3.49a | 6.21±3.15a | 6.23±3.34a | 7.82±2.50a |
Sweet | 6.71±2.88a | 7.08±2.92a | 5.63±2.37a | 7.02±3.07a | 6.01±3.18a | 7.46±3.44a | 6.77±2.98a | |
Fresh | 7.19±2.94a | 6.93±3.63a | 5.54±3.14b | 7.73±3.35a | 7.07±3.33a | 6.99±3.11a | 7.75±3.27a | |
Taste | Sour | 7.64±3.31a | 5.78±3.44b | 7.27±2.95a | 5.83±2.88b | 5.76±2.98b | 6.89±3.93bc | 8.45±3.17a |
Sweet | 4.92±2.29b | 8.78±2.68a | 4.79±2.70b | 7.73±3.52a | 4.76±3.23b | 8.77±2.82a | 9.17±2.40a | |
Bitter | 4.22±3.35a | 2.81±2.36a | 3.89±2.67a | 3.17±2.65a | 3.58±3.31a | 2.88±2.08a | 2.71±2.51a | |
Fresh | 4.98±2.92b | 5.30±3.28b | 4.15±2.69b | 5.63±3.12b | 3.89±2.93c | 5.71±2.74b | 7.43±3.06a | |
Tasteless | 6.02±4.03a | 3.59±2.99b | 5.51±3.15b | 3.80±2.70c | 7.53±3.48a | 3.17±2.78b | 1.86±1.90c | |
Off flavor | 4.00±3.16ab | 2.89±2.52ab | 4.52±3.17a | 2.14±1.85b | 3.62±2.74ab | 2.39±1.67ab | 1.86±1.54b | |
Texture | Hardness | 7.08±2.78a | 7.35±3.30a | 6.96±2.28a | 7.45±2.60a | 7.54±2.03a | 7.36±2.82a | 6.84±3.55a |
Toughness of granule | 7.35±2.23a | 8.01±3.21a | 7.98±2.27a | 8.23±2.48a | 7.68±2.11a | 7.99±2.26a | 8.64±1.90a | |
Juiciness | 7.29±2.64b | 7.83±2.55b | 8.06±2.70a | 8.02±2.32a | 7.50±2.67b | 9.33±1.62a | 9.13±1.94a | |
Tough feel | 4.93±2.73b | 4.66±3.21b | 6.86±3.08ab | 6.04±3.15bc | 8.12±2.66a | 7.75±4.11a | 4.14±1.95b | |
After taste | Sour | 6.09±3.78a | 4.70±3.45ab | 5.24±3.08ab | 3.64±2.66bc | 4.06±3.25b | 4.51±3.24ab | 6.13±3.78a |
Sweet | 2.95±1.72b | 6.69±3.26a | 3.23±1.98b | 5.60±3.61a | 2.65±2.09b | 6.27±3.68a | 6.50±3.03a | |
Bitter | 4.46±3.56a | 3.65±2.83a | 3.61±2.43a | 3.71±3.10a | 4.11±3.27a | 3.83±2.81a | 3.45±2.05a |