Table 4. Changes in texture properties of loaf bread with lactic acid bacteria cultured and cinnamon extract
Samples1) | Storage time (days) |
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
Hardness | Control | 5.54±0.812)b3)D4) | 5.96±0.46cD | 8.10±0.68bC | 8.15±0.31cC | 8.84±0.72cB | 10.30±0.41dA |
CE0 | 3.31±0.28dE | 4.56±0.30dD | 6.62±0.42cC | 7.05±0.59dBC | 7.44±0.34dAB | 7.68±0.78eA |
CE25 | 3.58±0.49dD | 4.95±0.58dC | 6.70±0.48cB | 6.87±0.41dB | 7.52±0.57dA | 7.83±0.42eA |
CE50 | 4.55±0.53cE | 5.56±0.82cD | 6.82±0.38cC | 7.88±0.69cB | 8.41±0.94cB | 11.12±0.59cA |
CE75 | 6.09±0.45bD | 8.32±0.36bC | 8.54±0.36bC | 9.54±0.56bB | 12.20±0.47bA | 12.42±0.49bA |
CE100 | 6.92±0.78aF | 9.10±0.57aE | 10.10±0.40aD | 11.80±0.48aC | 13.24±0.62aB | 15.13±0.97aA |
Adhesiveness | Control | 0.39±0.06A | 0.39±0.06A | 0.38±0.05A | 0.34±0.04aAB | 0.31±0.05aB | 0.28±0.06aB |
CE0 | 0.40±0.06 | 0.39±0.05 | 0.38±0.06 | 0.37±0.06a | 0.36±0.03a | 0.33±0.09a |
CE25 | 0.40±0.04A | 0.38±0.04AB | 0.36±0.05AB | 0.36±0.04aAB | 0.34±0.04aBC | 0.30±0.04aC |
CE50 | 0.40±0.04A | 0.40±0.05A | 0.36±0.06AB | 0.36±0.06aAB | 0.33±0.06aB | 0.27±0.06aC |
CE75 | 0.40±0.04A | 0.39±0.03A | 0.38±0.03A | 0.38±0.03aA | 0.33±0.04aB | 0.33±0.05aB |
CE100 | 0.40±0.05A | 0.40±0.03A | 0.34±0.03B | 0.23±0.05bC | 0.21±0.04bCD | 0.18±0.04bD |
Springiness | Control | 0.90±0.00bA | 0.89±0.01bB | 0.88±0.00bC | 0.87±0.01aC | 0.81±0.01bD | 0.81±0.01bD |
CE0 | 0.91±0.01aA | 0.90±0.02abA | 0.89±0.00aA | 0.88±0.01aB | 0.86±0.02aB | 0.83±0.01aC |
CE25 | 0.90±0.00bAB | 0.90±0.01aA | 0.89±0.01aB | 0.87±0.01aC | 0.80±0.01bcD | 0.78±0.02cE |
CE50 | 0.90±0.01bA | 0.89±0.00abB | 0.88±0.00abB | 0.84±0.01bC | 0.80±0.01bcD | 0.68±0.01dE |
CE75 | 0.89±0.00cA | 0.89±0.00bA | 0.88±0.01bB | 0.81±0.02cC | 0.79±0.01cD | 0.52±0.01eE |
CE100 | 0.82±0.00dA | 0.79±0.01cB | 0.76±0.01cC | 0.69±0.01dD | 0.46±0.01dE | 0.33±0.01fF |
Cohesiveness | Control | 0.52±0.02aA | 0.50±0.07aAB | 0.48±0.01bBC | 0.47±0.01abC | 0.46±0.00aC | 0.43±0.01bD |
CE0 | 0.52±0.01aA | 0.48±0.00abB | 0.48±0.00bB | 0.45±0.01bcC | 0.44±0.03bC | 0.42±0.01bD |
CE25 | 0.52±0.01aA | 0.46±0.01bB | 0.45±0.00cB | 0.45±0.04bcBC | 0.43±0.01bcC | 0.40±0.02cD |
CE50 | 0.51±0.05abA | 0.50±0.01aA | 0.50±0.00aA | 0.47±0.01aB | 0.47±0.01aB | 0.46±0.01aB |
CE75 | 0.51±0.02abA | 0.48±0.01abB | 0.47±0.02bB | 0.44±0.00cC | 0.41±0.02cdD | 0.40±0.00cE |
CE100 | 0.49±0.01bA | 0.46±0.02bB | 0.41±0.01dC | 0.39±0.01dD | 0.39±0.03dD | 0.37±0.01dE |
Gumminess | Control | 2.92±0.48bC | 3.02±0.55bC | 3.88±0.36bB | 3.80±0.15cB | 4.09±0.35bAB | 4.38±0.20cA |
CE0 | 1.71±0.14dC | 2.18±0.14cB | 3.17±0.21cdA | 3.18±0.27dA | 3.28±0.33cA | 3.26±0.29dA |
CE25 | 1.86±0.25dC | 2.27±0.27cB | 3.04±0.22dA | 3.07±0.41dA | 3.23±0.29cA | 3.16±0.18dA |
CE50 | 2.32±0.40cE | 2.78±0.43bD | 3.38±0.20cC | 3.72±0.35cBC | 3.96±0.48bB | 5.10±0.35bA |
CE75 | 3.09±0.29abC | 3.99±0.21aB | 4.02±0.28abB | 4.16±0.25bB | 5.04±0.26aA | 4.91±0.21bA |
CE100 | 3.38±0.39aE | 4.20±0.32aD | 4.14±0.20aD | 4.65±0.18aC | 5.21±0.53aB | 5.67±0.43aA |
Chewiness | Control | 2.62±0.43aB | 2.69±0.49bB | 3.40±0.31aA | 3.30±0.15aA | 3.31±0.31bA | 3.56±0.19aA |
CE0 | 1.55±0.12cC | 1.96±0.15cB | 2.83±0.17cdA | 2.78±0.25bA | 2.84±0.32cA | 2.70±0.26bA |
CE25 | 1.67±0.22cC | 2.05±0.25cB | 2.70±0.17dA | 2.66±0.37bA | 2.58±0.24cdA | 2.47±0.13cA |
CE50 | 2.10±0.36bD | 2.48±0.38bC | 2.99±0.18bcB | 3.14±0.27aB | 3.18±0.37bAB | 3.48±0.22aA |
CE75 | 2.74±0.27aC | 3.55±0.18aB | 3.52±0.23aB | 3.35±0.18aB | 3.99±0.24aA | 2.54±0.13bcC |
CE100 | 2.78±0.32aB | 3.33±0.24aA | 3.13±0.16bA | 3.19±0.12aA | 2.41±0.22dC | 1.89±0.16dD |
1)Control, water 700 g; CE0, water 670 g+lactic acid bacteria cultured 30 g; CE25, water 670 g+lactic acid bacteria cultured 22.5 g+cinnamon extract 7.5 g; CE50, water 670 g+lactic acid bacteria cultured 15 g+cinnamon extract 15 g; CE75, water 670 g+lactic acid bacteria cultured 7.5 g+cinnamon extract 22.5 g; CE100, water 670 g+cinnamon extract 30 g.
2)All values are mean±SD. Mean with different superscript within a column are significantly different (p<0.05) by Duncan's multiple range test.
3)a-eMeans Duncan's multiple range test for different addition (column).
4)A-FMeans Duncan's multiple range test for storage time (row).