ClO2 gas conc. (ppm) | 0 | 15 | 30 | 45 | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Time (min) | 0 | 15 | 30 | 45 | 15 | 30 | 45 | 15 | 30 | 45 | |
Hardness (g) | 1day | 298.50±77.13 | 330.92±110.89ay | 275.33±65.07ay | 274.92±46.98ay | 285.58±64.19ay | 237.67±55.21ay | 257.92±69.82ay | 360.08±49.69ay | 258.08±87.43ay | 249.14±53.56ay |
2day | 437.58±57.36ay | 445.58±57.51ay | 492.83±176.99axy | 549.33±130.11ax | 423.17±113.05axy | 642.58±178.24ax | 543.50±154.78ax | 539.54±65.73ax | 456.14±76.72axy | 547.92±120.23ax | |
3day | 725.25±75.21ax | 688.92±152.9ax | 756.08±212.21ax | 654.70±123.10abx | 623.15±203.28abcx | 552.08±114.34abcx | 368.25±48.78cxy | 414.58±98.83bcxy | 542.25±146.74abcx | 681.24±140.13abx | |
Adhesiveness (mJ) | 1day | 0.51±0.21abz | 0.51±0.17abz | 0.79±0.16aby | 0.65±0.09abz | 0.50±0.14abz | 0.46±0.14bz | 0.39±0.21by | 0.94±0.48ay | 0.72±0.38abz | 0.46±0.17by |
2day | 2.18±0.83cdy | 1.99±0.50cdy | 9.22±1.61bx | 1.32±0.15dy | 3.55±0.59cdx | 4.04±0.56cx | 2.53±0.35cdx | 15.73±3.07ax | 1.81±0.18cdy | 1.53±0.76dy | |
3day | 4.04±1.08cx | 5.77±1.09bx | 2.37±0.14fy | 3.86±0.37cdx | 1.78±0.55ey | 2.27±0.29ey | 2.47±0.75dex | 2.69±0.95cdey | 3.04±0.42cdex | 7.33±1.18ax | |
Resilience | 1day | 0.23±0.13ax | 0.19±0.01abx | 0.14±0.01bx | 0.17±0.01abx | 0.19±0.01abx | 0.16±0.02abx | 0.19±0.01abx | 0.15±0.01aby | 0.15±0.01abx | 0.17±0.01abx |
2day | 0.06±0.01by | 0.08±0.01by | 0.07±0.01bz | 0.10±0.02by | 0.05±0.01bz | 0.08±0.02by | 0.07±0.02by | 0.75±0.14ax | 0.13±0.05bx | 0.10±0.05by | |
3day | 0.06±0.01cdy | 0.07±0.01cy | 0.09±0.01by | 0.05±0.01dz | 0.11±0.01ay | 0.07±0.01cy | 0.06±0.01cdy | 0.06±0.01cdy | 0.09±0.01bx | 0.05±0.01dy | |
Cohesiveness | 1day | 0.54±0.01by | 0.57±0.01bx | 0.50±0.10bx | 0.54±0.07bx | 0.55±0.06bx | 0.52±0.03bx | 0.55±0.05bx | 0.48±0.04bx | 0.51±0.03bx | 1.88±0.27ax |
2day | 0.35±0.01dy | 0.37±0.01dy | 0.38±0.05cdx | 0.43±0.04aby | 0.37±0.03dy | 0.39±0.01bcdy | 0.42±0.02abcy | 0.38±0.02cdy | 0.44±0.01ay | 0.38±0.01cdy | |
3day | 1.72±0.21ax | 0.55±0.02bx | 0.45±0.11bcdx | 0.36±0.02cdy | 0.44±0.01bcdy | 0.39±0.02cdy | 0.31±0.01dz | 0.36±0.01cdy | 0.48±0.03bcxy | 0.55±0.04by | |
Springiness (mm) | 1day | 4.81±0.20cy | 5.84±0.54abz | 5.00±0.55bcy | 4.93±0.48cy | 6.02±0.88ay | 4.63±0.36cy | 5.12±0.47bcy | 5.02±0.21bcy | 4.66±0.19cy | 5.08±0.24bcz |
2day | 9.18±1.18abcx | 9.64±1.21abcy | 8.24±0.54bcx | 8.97±0.77abcx | 7.92±0.86cy | 10.96±1.28ax | 10.18±1.77abx | 8.33±1.76bcx | 10.94±0.72ax | 9.92±0.67abcy | |
3day | 10.55±1.08bcx | 13.80±1.19ax | 9.32±1.21cdx | 9.21±1.28cdx | 10.24±1.16bcx | 9.73±1.04cdx | 8.64±1.07cdx | 7.71±1.11dx | 12.25±1.31abx | 12.89±1.94ax | |
Gumminess (g) | 1day | 151.83±16.88bcy | 186.97±12.78ay | 78ay 138.60±17.64cdz | 148.02±16.03cdy | 158.65±12.66bcy | 122.72±12.72dz | 141.75±11.62cdy | 176.45±12.40aby | 138.58±16.97cdz | 135.12±12.83cdz |
2day | 152.27±13.98ey | 165.22±15.25dey | 195.47±18.47cdy | 219.97±16.65bcx | 156.33±18.67ey | 249.23±14.55bx | 311.82±25.92ax | 244.18±17.66bx | 195.28±14.15cdy | 208.82±18.38cy | |
3day | 268.73±13.34bx | 326.05±18.68ax | 315.22±11.03ax | 240.42±14.02cdx | 270.22±17.42bx | 214.93±14.31dy 113.28±15.21fy | 147.07±14.33ey | 33ey 248.27±14.54bcx | 340.13±18.47ax | ||
Chewiness (mJ) | 1day | 7.37±0.93cdz | 10.86±1.06ax | 6.94±0.65dz | 7.23±0.81cdz | 8.45±0.51bcz | 5.35±0.69ez | 7.19±0.58cdy | 9.22±0.66bcy | 6.86±0.42dz | 6.75±0.53dz |
1day | 14.73±0.81efy | 15.76±1.51defy | 17.93±1.37bcdey | 19.59±1.83bcdy | 13.80±1.36efy | 16.73±1.05cdey | 41.21±5.29ax | 12.36±1.28fx | 20.96±1.51by | 20.14±1.77bcy | |
3day | 30.86±2.04cx | 47.81±2.18ax | 28.26±1.02cdex | 26.11±1.14ex | 26.92±1.29dex | 20.29±1.83fx | 9.08±1.79gy | 11.66±1.71gxy | 29.51±1.15cdx | 43.95±2.25bx |