Table 3
Sensory evaluation of or iental melon mesocarp by qualitative descriptive analysis

Sensory attribute Oriental melon1)
OCI OCII OCIII OCVI OCV CC
Hyperdermal-Mesocarp andMesocarpappearance Opaque degree 6.32±2.16ab2) 5.99±1.94ab 5.95±1.83ab 5.87±1.88ab 5.80±2.07ab 6.62±1.70a
Proportion of mesocarp 5.77±1.48a 5.94±1.33a 5.25±1.38a 5.52±1.51a 5.28±1.45a 5.96±1.45a
Green intensity 6.63±1.75a 4.59±1.89b 4.70±1.98b 4.91±2.13b 4.96±2.02b 4.75±1.75b
Endocarpappearance(seed cavity Transparency 5.28±2.32a 5.42±2.32a 5.55±2.05a 5.41±2.08a 5.73±2.16a 4.98±2.39a
Attachment intensity 6.74±1.89a 4.84±2.13c 6.73±1.71a 5.75±1.96b 7.03±1.74a 6.77±1.64a
Crack degree of endocarp 2.31±1.57d 3.75±2.66c 5.34±2.73b 3.62±2.50c 6.38±2.61a 5.37±2.97b
Color of central core 7.55±1.00a 6.71±1.56b 4.41±1.77d 6.88±1.19b 5.03±1.72c 2.32±1.26e
Size of seed 7.23±1.19a 6.10±1.62b 4.31±1.91c 6.56±1.40b 4.35±1.81c 3.37±1.48d
Mesocarp aroma Sweet 5.14±2.23b 5.82±1.93a 6.02±1.82a 6.05±1.81a 6.10±1.94a 6.49±1.70a
Unique oriental melon 6.24±2.06a 6.24±1.90a 6.13±1.75a 6.35±1.83a 6.46±1.80a 6.59±1.76a
Cucumber 4.75±2.20a 4.34±2.17a 3.98±2.23ab 4.17±2.26a 4.00±2.13ab 3.32±1.92b
Radish 4.77±2.29a 3.66±2.01b 3.17±1.72b 3.74±2.01b 3.06±1.70b 3.37±2.04b
greenish 3.53±2.01a 2.69±1.58b 2.42±1.25b 2.64±1.51b 2.48±1.41b 2.31±1.19b
Endocarp aroma(seed cavity) Sweet 6.12±1.72a 6.67±1.44a 6.59±1.64a 6.45±1.76a 6.44±1.65a 6.71±1.64a
Unique oriental melon 6.31±1.64a 6.84±1.51a 6.57±1.60a 6.71±1.60a 6.66±1.73a 6.57±1.75a
Over ripening oriental melon 3.91±2.05ab 4.19±2.27b 4.13±2.34b 4.14±2.44b 3.88±2.32ab 5.53±2.26a
Mesocarptaste Sweet 5.66±1.69bc 6.28±1.65a 5.39±1.66c 6.12±1.60ab 6.37±1.69a 6.55±1.59a
Unique oriental melon 5.53±1.85bc 6.13±1.77ab 5.46±2.03c 6.16±1.68ab 6.42±1.85a 5.89±1.82abc
Bitterness 2.87±1.76a 2.53±1.54a 2.60±1.63a 2.69±1.64a 2.35±1.31a 2.67±1.83a
Cucumber 4.14±1.90a 3.16±1.80c 3.87±1.88ab 3.44±1.90bc 3.50±2.04ab 3.25±1.86bc
Sourness 2.57±1.50a 2.56±1.65a 3.12±2.03a 3.05±1.76a 2.74±1.75a 2.99±1.96a
Over ripe 3.50±1.96bc 3.69±2.31bc 2.99±1.72c 3.85±2.09b 3.25±1.96bc 5.21±2.41a
Greenish 3.14±1.88a 2.24±1.35c 2.87±1.72ab 2.56±1.53bc 2.52±1.40bc 2.06±1.10c
Mesocarp andendocarptexture Hardness 5.92±1.48ab 5.39±1.57c 5.82±1.39abc 5.48±1.30bc 6.09±1.48a 5.96±1.47ab
Juiciness 5.52±1.67b 6.38±1.64a 5.57±1.72b 6.39±1.42a 6.24±1.52a 6.07±1.78ab
Crunchy 6.21±1.61a 5.87±1.61a 5.75±1.67a 5.85±1.41a 6.20±1.59a 6.34±1.55a
Content of seed 6.28±1.73a 5.46±1.77bc 4.94±1.70cd 5.98±1.56ab 5.39±1.82bc 4.62±2.09d
Hardness of seed 6.37±1.57a 5.39±1.87b 3.82±1.58c 5.84±1.90ab 4.23±1.74c 3.12±1.82d
Mealiness of mesocarp 3.16±1.51ab 3.24±1.72ab 3.62±1.85a 2.88±1.46b 2.89±1.53b 2.89±1.61b
After taste Sweet 4.67±2.17ab 5.37±2.30a 4.32±2.22b 5.03±2.18ab 5.32±2.22a 5.35±2.36a
Astringency 2.92±1.75a 2.70±1.51a 3.09±1.82a 2.70±1.60a 2.57±1.57a 2.52±1.53a
Sour 2.57±1.46a 2.34±1.27a 2.66±1.54a 2.74±1.52a 2.59±1.54a 2.71±1.30a
Acridity 3.34±1.95a 2.88±1.84a 3.07±1.94a 2.95±1.80a 2.71±1.70a 2.89±1.85a
1)OCI-OCV, organic cultivation according to farm; CC, conventional cultivation.
2)Means±SD within each column followed by the same letter are not significantly different(p<0.05).