Table 2.
Changes in the isoflavone contents dur ing the fermentation of Cheonggukjang without and with BMP using B. subtilis CSY191

Cheonggukjang with BMP (%)1) Fermentation time (hr) Isoflavone contents2) (μg/g) Total
Glycosides Malonylglycosides Acetylglycosides Aglycones
Daidzin Glycitin Genistin Daidzin Glycitin Genistin Daidzin Glycitin Genistin Daidzein Glycitein Genistein
0% 0 570.77 224.63 589.16 91.02 31.06 144.56 nd3 nd nd 30.98 86.78 33.85 1802.81
±22.83a ±11.23bc ±23.57ab ±3.64b ±1.55d ±5.78b ±1.24e ±4.34a ±1.35a ±72.11a
12 558.91a 266.72b 581.48ab 116.1ab 54.39bc 177.88a nd nd nd 127.88d 72.35a 26.81ab 1982.52a
±27.95 ±1067 ±29.07 ±5.81 ±2.18 ±8.85 ±6.39 ±2.89 ±1.34 ±99.13
24 376.23 186.27 432.79 118.70b 46.57 177.61 nd nd nd 261.28 56.39 33.77 1689.61
±15.05b ±9.31c ±17.31b ±4.75a ±2.33c ±7.10a ±10.45bc ±2.82b ±1.35a ±84.48b
48 249.91c 182.53c 250.91c 125.77a 84.78b 146.84b 19.35b nd nd 369.15b 34.07c 29.48a 1492.79c
±10.00 ±9.13 ±10.04 ±5.03 ±4.24 ±5.87 ±0.77 ±14.77 ±1.70 ±1.18 ±74.67
72 249.66 273.21 217.42 126.71 115.23 134.66 40.21 nd nd 563.32 21.28 14.31 1756.01
±9.99 ±13.66b ±8.70bc ±5.07a ±5.76a ±5.39b ±1.16a ±22.53a ±1.06cd ±0.57c ±70.24b
1.0% 0 612.92 214.11 662.03 98.61 31.80 157.28 nd nd nd 29.62 82.10 25.48 1913.95
±24.52a ±10.71bc ±26.48a ±3.94b ±1.59d ±6.29ab ±1.18e ±4.11a ±1.02ab ±76.56a
12 568.71 223.37 603.28 109.87 37.46 175.11 nd nd nd 114.09 72.88 19.99 1924.76
±28.44a ±8.93bc ±30.16ab ±4.39ab ±1.87c ±7.00a ±4.56d ±3.64a ±0.80b ±96.24a
24 423.57 205.85 441.26 97.13 44.38 149.84 nd nd nd 217.27 57.48 27.61 1664.39
±16.94b ±10.29c ±17.65b ±3.89b ±2.22c ±5.99b ±8.69c ±2.87b ±1.10ab ±83.22bc
48 281.63 206.63 287.00 142.54 85.08 165.96 19.38 nd nd 378.21 36.23 31.05 1633.71
±14.08c ±8.27c ±14.35bc ±7.13a ±3.40b ±8.30ab ±0.78b ±15.13ab ±1.81c ±1.24a ±65.35bc
72 259.19c 359.58 248.44c 124.46a 102.25a 141.52b 22.91b nd nd 437.32b 23.02cd 22.82b 1741.51b
±10.37 ±17.98 ±9.94 ±4.98 ±5.11 ±5.66 ±0.92 ±17.49 ±1.15 ±0.91 ±87.08
2.5% 0 607.98 219.47 636.51 56.52 28.19 103.01 nd nd nd 22.57 32.14 20.38 1726.77
±24.32a ±10.98bc ±25.46a ±2.26c ±1.14d ±4.12cd ±0.90f ±1.61c ±0.82b ±69.07b
12 542.03a 216.66bc 543.89b 90.67b 30.85d 147.84b nd nd nd 83.49 60.50b 14.87c 1730.80b
±21.68 ±10.83 ±21.76 ±3.36 ±1.54 ±5.91 ±3.34 ±3.03 ±0.59 ±86.54
24 414.72 209.10 435.23 106.37 49.98 146.83 nd nd nd 194.56 46.64 21.22 1624.65
±20.74b ±8.36c ±21.76b ±5.32ab ±2.00bc ±7.34b ±7.78c ±2.33bc ±0.85b ±64.99bc
48 256.17c 173.08c 258.07c 122.97a 87.05b 144.43b 22.86b nd nd 412.96b 22.39cd 25.87ab 1525.85c
±10.25 ±8.65 ±10.32 ±4.92 ±4.35 ±5.78 ±0.91 ±20.65 ±0.90 ±23.06 ±76.29
72 218.69c 223.95bc 188.68d 97.43b 79.82b 115.38c 9.28 d nd nd 395.23b 15.67d 26.09ab 1370.22d
±8.75 ±11.20 ±7.55 ±3.90 ±3.99 ±4.62 ±0.37 ±15.81 ±0.78 ±1.04 ±54.81
5.0% 0 583.28a 259.44b 616.82ab 54.40c 33.89cd 99.06cd nd nd nd 18.79f 90.43a 16.85c 1772.96b
±23.33 ±12.97 ±24.67 ±2.18 ±1.69 ±3.96 ±0.75 ±4.52 ±0.67 ±70.92
12 571.35 221.22 591.76 51.52 27.06 92.40 nd nd nd 48.11 77.42 15.96 1696.80
±28.57a ±8.85bc ±29.59ab ±2.58c ±1.08d ±4.62d ±1.92e ±3.87a ±0.64c ±84.84bc
24 431.86 224.76 454.72 61.82 29.52 93.35 nd nd nd 168.30 55.23 18.69 1538.25
±17.27b ±11.24bc ±18.19b ±2.47bc ±1.48d ±3.73d ±6.73cd ±2.76b ±0.75b ±61.53c
48 319.76bc 446.70a 324.39bc 96.08b 63.70bc 112.09c 8.28 d nd nd 294.31c 37.13c 24.65ab 1727.09b
±12.79 ±22.34 ±12.98 ±3.84 ±3.19 ±4.48 ±0.33 ±11.77 ±1.86 ±0.99 ±86.35
72 370.17b 276.68b 136.05e 83.43b 77.56b 96.88cd 14.03c nd nd 390.57b 26.25cd 36.22a 1507.84c
±18.51 ±11.07 ±6.80 ±3.34 ±3.88 ±3.88 ±0.56 ±15.62 ±1.31 ±1.45 ±60.31
Cheonggukjang fermented without BMP and with 1-5% (w/w) of BMP.
All values are means of determinations in three independent experiments. Means with different lowercase letters (a, b, c, d, and e) indicate significant (p<0.05) differences of fermentation times by Tukey’s multiple range test.
nd: not detected.